Many police commanders claim that despite a flood of resignations that began with the pandemic and the 2020 unrest, staffing levels have not recovered.


2017 saw the graduation of the New York City Police Department’s newest recruits at the Theater at Madison Square Garden. Credit…

In Washington American police departments are wooing recruits using some of the same strategies a football coach might use to sign a prized quarterback as they try to reverse an exodus of unhappy cops and a precipitous fall in applications.

Future officers are treated to a “signing day” ceremony in Fairfax County, Va., a suburb of Washington, where they formally accept their employment offers.

Out-of-state citizens who want to join the Louisville, Kentucky, police department are being flown in to take admission exams, stay in a hotel, and go on a ride-along with an officer.

Some agencies on the West Coast are enticing officers from other departments to transfer with bonuses of tens of thousands of dollars.

The economics of law enforcement have long been skewed in favour of police forces, which frequently had many more competent candidates than unfilled positions. not anymore. Since the onset of the pandemic and the unrest in 2020, there has been a sharp decline in the number of persons seeking to become police officers. This has given job seekers enormous leverage, prompting departments to sell themselves in novel ways.

Marcus Jones, the police chief of Montgomery County, Maryland, declared that “the game has certainly shifted” after learning that a rival agency was utilising location-based digital advertising to advertise jobs near his police stations.

Following the murder of George Floyd in 2020, protests across the country heard calls to drastically change policing and direct resources to other organisations. These calls, however, have since subsided. Police chiefs, though, claim that they are still dealing with the effects of those months.

Officials from departments around the nation expressed their struggles at a recent meeting in Washington organised by the Police Executive Research Forum, a group that promotes law enforcement policy. They said they could not locate enough people who were willing and able to fight crime, fill open positions, and increase community confidence in the police.


Chief Adrian Diaz of the Seattle Police Department said, “I need an officer who’s actually going to be the community engagement officer, but also can respond to that active shooter.” Hundreds of cops left his department as a result of the upheaval in 2020, which in his city included a so-called autonomous zone and a police station that the department had to vacate for weeks.

Especially at a period when “Defund the Police” became a mainstay of political discourse, Chief Diaz claimed that many departing police felt undervalued by politicians and locals. While some of the retiring officers joined departments in the suburbs after accepting signing incentives, others completely left the field. Despite the fact that Seattle now provides a $30,000 bonus of its own for officers currently assigned to other cities who transfer to the city and a $7,500 signing bonus for new hires, Chief Diaz claimed that recruiting is still proving challenging. Once they graduate from the academy, new police officers in Seattle make about $83,000 yearly, while transferred experienced officers start out making more than $90,000.

The American economy is undergoing a larger restructuring at the same time as the officer shortages. Low

People in many professions feel more confident to seek greater compensation, different career paths, or more time off to spend with family because of low unemployment rates, a large number of vacant jobs, and the expansion of remote work. Additionally, many police departments were already struggling with a glut of officers who were very close to retirement.

But there is universal consensus among police chiefs that the murder of Mr. Floyd by the Minneapolis police and the ensuing nationwide demonstrations and unrest are directly, though not solely, related to the shrinking of the law enforcement talent pool.


Image source :

It wasn’t just what happened in Minneapolis; it was felt nationwide in a manner it never has been,” said Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum. I think that’s taken its toll, either on potential candidates or current officers contemplating what it means to be a cop in America today, he continued.

Federal figures on police employment are not fully available in the present. Resignations were up 43% in 2021 compared to 2019 and retirements were up 24%, according to a poll of 184 police agencies this year by Mr. Wexler’s group. Even though there were more new hires in 2021 than in 2020, hiring in such departments decreased dramatically during the same two-year period. Numerous of those tendencies

According to Brandon Buskey, the head of the American Civil Liberties Union’s Criminal Law Reform Project, communities looking for additional officers should think about adopting non-policing public safety initiatives.

Since the 2020 protests, Mr. Buskey said he has been disappointed by a “return to the status quo of relying on police,” as tough-on-crime rhetoric has overshadowed some of the protesters’ most comprehensive demands to reform law enforcement, eradicate systemic racism, and reevaluate public safety spending.

That is the precise discussion that needs to take place, according to Mr. Buskey: “Whether the challenges in retention and recruitment suggest that we should look at how we truly deliver safety and what are the best uses of public resources.”


Image source :

In Minneapolis, where the city council recently approved $7,000 retention incentives for officers to stay on the force, constituents last year rejected a plan to overhaul the city’s police force and personnel numbers have plunged. Police recruiters are more successful in San Francisco, where there are many job openings, with middle-aged candidates seeking a change of employment. Additionally, Commissioner Michael Harrison of Baltimore claimed that a flight of police to suburban agencies had led to a vicious cycle wherein fewer city officers were being forced to perform more job in already challenging circumstances.

In order to prevent as much crime as possible, we must make up for the absence of officers by having quick response times, being able to patrol, and being visible. As much as possible,” Mr. Harrison added. “We sometimes have to make them do it, sometimes we have to cancel their off days to make them do it,” he continued. And that lowers morale.